Should pregnant drug users be prosecuted

The billsent to Gov. The American Society of Addiction Medicine: These approaches treat addiction as a moral failing.

Should pregnant drug users be prosecuted

The strict, draconian proposal seems to have support on both sides of the political spectrum and despite objections from the medical community.

It seems that state officials are turning to a punitive approach in order to address the growing trend in babies being born addicted to drugs — legal or not.

Beginning last year, Tennessee now forces staff at every hospital to start reporting such cases, and the numbers are still spiking. And, in the face of these troubling, rising numbers, health officials have made drug-dependent babies a priority and the state government is turning to drastic measures.

Women finding themselves in this sort of situation would now have the option to seek treatment for their substance abuse. John DeBerry acknowledges that it seems unnatural to punish a pregnant woman for causing harm to her unborn child but seems to lack foresight into other options.

Pros and Cons Cons The obvious cons to taking this punitive approach to addressing the issue of babies being born with neonatal abstinence syndrome is that addicts will be jailed for having an untreated chronic medical condition.

Should pregnant drug users be prosecuted

Pregnant women and new mothers could face reckless endangerment charges, which is a misdemeanor, or charges that range to aggravated assault; an assault charge could mean 15 years behind bars. An approach that is punitive, even with its option to seek treatment, will drive away women in need of help and may even encourage more abortions.

She makes an excellent point:A former student in Arizona's impoverished Safford Unified School District felt, quite rightly, that school administrators violated her constitutional protections when they strip-searched her in search of prescription-strength ibuprofen in Should pregnant drug users be prosecuted?

I had a very equal amount for gender, and a range of different aged people taking the survey so the results could vary Many of the students thought pregnant drug users should be placed into a rehab program rather than a jail cell. Update June 28, - The initiative has qualified for the ballot "Joint" Legislative Informational Hearing: Marijuana Legalization.

Initiative Statute.

What’s wrong with making it a crime to be pregnant and to have a drug problem

5/24/ The Adult Use of Marijuana Act is a marijuana legalization initiative that is being proposed for the November, California ballot.. AUMA is an elaborate, page initiative which writes hundreds of new provisions and regulations.

Should pregnant women who use drugs get punished? Should pregnant women who use drugs get punished? Vote Up 2 Vote Down. 34 Comments by Likes | Date. I see the arguments for and against punishment for drug-using pregnant women. It's far too complicated for there to be harsh punishments or no punishments at all, though.

Criminalizing pregnant women who use illegal drugs: ‘Throwing a lit match’ her illegal use of a narcotic drug taken while pregnant where they are prosecuted under laws for posing some. MORAL AND SOCIAL ISSUES REGARDING PREGNANT WOMEN WHO USE AND ABUSE DRUGS Kenneth A.

DeVille, PhD, JD, and Loretta M. Kopelman, PhD How should society respond to pregnant women using recreational or addictive drugs that may harm their future children?

During the past was observed in children with no drug exposure who lived in underpriv-.

Buffalo Police Then and Now